INTRODUCING THE AR PRACTICE   ·   A practical field guide to artificial resources, work and people
Artificial Resources / Balance Scorecard
THE AR FIELD GUIDE / Balance Scorecard

Value with eyes open.

A configurable demonstration of balanced AI evaluation. Adjust the scenario, scores, weights and minimum safeguards; explore what changes.

Demonstration, not certification. The figures and thresholds are hypothetical and are not validated organisational measures. Use this to structure questions and identify evidence to collect, not to authorise a real AI deployment.
01 / CONFIGURE THE CASE

Explore a scenario

Start with a sample use case or create your own. The four scores are editable judgements, not observations.

Usable work, speed, outcomes and full costs — not activity alone.

Accuracy, completeness, consistency and fitness for purpose.

Testing, traceability, monitoring, escalation and recoverability.

Workload, autonomy, learning, trust and wellbeing.

Advanced configuration: weights and safeguards

Weights affect the illustrative combined index only. Minimum safeguards are evaluated independently and cannot be offset by a high score elsewhere.

Weights are normalised automatically.

02 / INTERPRET THE BALANCE

Illustrative weighted index

65 / 100
Review before scaling
Business effectivenessOutput qualityAssurance & controlHuman impact
Review gaps before expansion.
↑ Opportunity to explore

Improve consistency while preserving service quality.

↓ Risk to address

Understand the human impact of the proposed workflow.

The index is an explanatory aid only. Even a high index is not a pass, certificate or substitute for evidence. No entries are sent to a server.

HOW TO USE THE EXAMPLE

Keep the conversation
honest and complete.

01

Set a baseline

Compare with what people do today — including defects, time, costs and the experience of those involved.

02

Replace opinions with evidence

Design meaningful trials, sample outputs and gather worker feedback before using scores operationally.

03

Keep red lines visible

Define unacceptable outcomes and minimum safeguards separately from any averaged performance index.

↑ The opportunity

Where value can be created

  • Surface neglected dimensions early in procurement and pilot discussions.
  • Make disagreement about evidence and thresholds explicit.
  • Support a balanced narrative for sponsors, reviewers and affected workers.
↓ The risk

What needs attention

  • Invented or poorly calibrated numbers give a false sense of precision.
  • Weights can hide important failures if minimum requirements are ignored.
  • A good-looking aggregate number may discourage scrutiny of underlying evidence.
Decision checkpoint: Treat every number as an assumption until someone can show how it was measured.
MAKE THE NEXT DECISION BETTER

Take the thinking into your own process.

Download practical starter templates for decisions, resource ownership, assurance evidence and risk-opportunity tracking.